My last post was written before the iPhone announcement. This post is my initial early reaction, or the part I like to refer to as “Before Simon explains to me why I’m wrong”.
The thing that makes me feel bad is that I know some of you have been waiting for this phone. I mean really waiting, over-running the end of your contracts, just to wait for the next iPhone, and this is what Apple have given you. They took an extra four months over this handset and came out with something that would have been slightly dated back in June, and is just a joke now.
There’s no doubt that the iPhone 4S is better than the iPhone 4. That’s what the S stands for – better. Unfortunately I just don’t think it’s better enough. Lets take a look at it. For starters there’s a 1GHz dual core A5 chip, which Apple fans will tell you is just as good as the 1.5GHz dual core chips that are now available in Android phones, and will certainly be better than the 2GHz quad core chips we’re expecting to see in Android phones at the beginning of 2012. There’s a new 8MP camera that will apparently be a great deal better than every other 8MP Android phone. The retina display remains the same, but I’m sure it will in some way be classed as better than the higher resolution and bigger screened Android phones.
There’s also the new voice control. You’ll be able to control all sorts of things on your iPhone just by talking to it. For me personally, voice control still lives in the “I’ll believe it when I see it” category of technology. The voice control in Android works brilliantly in nice quiet environments. The noisy environment of a car, which is the only place I ever want to use it, just causes too many problems for it to actually work. Right now I’m willing to bet that the iPhone will work just as well, but of course I’m happy to be proved wrong with that one. Working or not, I’m not a fan of voice control, but I’m sure there’ll be some people out there who love it and use it many times each day.
And that’s your lot for iPhone 4S specific features. There are new functions added to iOS 5, but being honest, they read like a list of new features for a two version old copy of Android. For example, iOS 5 will include Apple versions of Google Talk, Android Notifications, and extremely limited social network integration that only works with Twitter.
Remember, I love Apple products. I’m writing this post on a MacBook while watching something on the AppleTV. As I look up from the screen, there are at least three iPods in my field of vision. However I think the iPhone continues to be the Emperor’s new clothes. Only Apple can put out a phone with features and technical specs that match an eight month old Android handset, and have the world call it amazing.
On the 11th of this month, Google and Samsung are going to announce the next Android Nexus phone. Expect it to have at least an 8MP camera, 1280x720p 4.5″ screen, and 1.5GHz processor. It will also come with the next version of Android, which we don’t really know anything about yet, except that it will have all the features of iOS 5 that are already in there.
So should you buy the iPhone 4S? I really can’t think of a compelling reason to do so. Not even if you’ve got a load of iOS apps. Just take the £200 you were planning to spend on the iPhone, get yourself the Nexus phone instead, buy Android versions of all your iOS apps, and then spend the remaining £150 on a nice treat for yourself. On Tech It Or Leave It, I said that iOS and Android were just too close to each other to keep arguing over which was better. Now I’m going back on that to say that the Apple emperor is actually naked. He doesn’t really have new clothes, just his meat and two veg hanging out there for all to see.
